High Court upholds judgement in Covid business interruption insurance case
The UK’s High Court has upheld its judgement in favour of policyholders, announced in September, on the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) business interruption insurance test case.
The group action lawsuit saw the financial regulator and a group of insurance and reinsurance companies seek legal clarity on whether insurers were obligated to pay out on business interruption (BI) claims related to the pandemic.
The FCA’s case against eight insurers was launched in June 2020 with the aim of clarifying whether 21 policy wordings, affecting potentially 700 types of policies, 60 insurers, 370,000 policyholders and up to £7.4bn in insurance claims, covered disruption and government-ordered closures to curb the virus.
In September, the High Court ruled that insurers Hiscox & QBE must pay out disputed business interruption policies to policy holders in the events industry, which include live music venues, clubs, pubs and bars across the UK. An appeal was granted.
Specialist insurance broker NDML and the Night Time Industries Association (NTIA) worked collectively to support affected companies. NTIA CEO Michael Kill said the judgement was a moral victory for thousands of businesses with Hiscox Business Interruption Insurance: “[They] have been placed under unnecessary financial hardship because of the legal process that has been drawn out much longer than was necessary by insurers”.
He said, “We are extremely pleased that the Supreme Court has dismissed the insurers’ appeal claims and supported the rights of thousands of businesses to be able to claim against there BI insurance”
“We still have some detail to interpret on many of the other policies that have been reviewed by the Supreme Court.
“I would like to thank the FCA for its support throughout this process and the legal guidance of Philip Kolvin QC through a very dark period for many businesses. “It is now very important that insurers do the right thing and expedite the payment process.”
Reacting to the news, UKHospitality chief executive Kate Nicholls said: “Obviously, we still need to pore over the details, but, at first glance, this looks like very positive news.
“Businesses took out policies in good faith and it is right that insurers stick to these agreements and honour claims.
“Should this result in pay-outs to policy holders – a point which is still not clear at present - this could provide an additional lifeline that many businesses desperately need. It could be the difference between keeping staff members on or being forced to let them go; it could mean the survival of a business that was previously staring collapse in the face.
“I would like to thank Taylor Wessing for all their hard work. We have been pushing hard for a positive resolution, and the legal insight that Taylor Wessing has provided to hospitality operators has been immense. Hopefully, this outcome will give many small businesses in the hospitality sector peace of mind and possibly some financial support they need to begin rebuilding.”